George Buck Mitre Planes, Part I: Towell, Spiers, Holland, and Norris

© 2020 – Martin Shepherd Piano Service   Using the text, research, or images on this website without permission on an ebay auction or any other site is a violation of federal law in most countries.

GEORGE BUCK tool supplier to the piano trade as well as others.

Norris-made Buck planes, c. 1908.

George Buck ad in “Modern Practical Joinery” by George Ellis, 1908. They offered bow drills, planes, tuning, voicing, and regulating tools to the piano trade. Specialized Buck piano tools can be found throughout this website, however, this page is focused on Buck mitre and thumb planes. For planes, George Buck carried the revered Norris line, but they put their own attractive mark on their tool merchandise. Buck has carried other infill plane makes during their long tenure in business, including Towell, Spiers, Holland, Slater, and Miller.

Matthew Buck, “File and Saw Maker,” in Robson’s 1820 London Trade Directory.

George Buck was born 30 October, 1805 to Matthew Buck (1776-1844) and Mary Tooth (1778-1810).    Matthew Buck was a saw and filemaker who worked out of 22 Peter Street, Clerkenwell from before 1819, until after 1833.

Matthew Buck, 22 Peter St. Clerkenwell, under “Saw Makers,” in the 1825-6 Pigot’s London Street Directory.

 

 

 

 

Ann Buck

The Buck extended family became a large tool dynasty with three separate businesses, two of which continue to trade into the 21st century. A couple of of George’s siblings also started major tool shops: Joseph Buck (1802-1884), whose business became Buck and Ryan, and Ann Buck (1807-1895), who married John Hickman Sr. (1806-1847), and they established Buck & Hickman in 1832.  In their early years, these businesses were quite intertwined.

“I. Buck” (Joseph, 11 July, 1802-18 April, 1884), at 1 Great Waterloo Street, Lambeth, in the 1825 London Trade Directory.

Horwood’s Plan of London, 1819 Edition, excerpt of Lambeth, with Great Waterloo St. and Gibson St.

 

The 1825 London Trade Directory would have been sent to print in the fall of 1824, when George’s older brother, Joseph Buck was only 22 years old.  Clearly, Joseph had access to some start up money.  Joseph expanded to other addresses in just a few short years: 1 Gibson St. Lambeth, 1826; 245 Tottenham Court Road, 1831; 124 Newgate St., London City, 1834.

 

1 Gibson Street and 1 Great Waterloo Street were either very close to each other, or they were indeed the same location.   The Royal Coburg Theatre (est.1818), later renamed the Victoria Theatre (c.1833), was listed as across Waterloo Rd. from the J. Buck warehouse in later directories, circa 1843-1890.  Various street numbers on Waterloo St./Rd. were renumbering rather than actual moves: 1 Great Waterloo St./1 Gibson St. (1824-1843); 91 Waterloo Rd. (1844-1863); 164 Waterloo Rd. (1867-1893).

Oakley Street ran into Gibson Street.  68 Oakley Street was planemaker John Holland’s address from 1861 to 1871.  This proximity likely fostered a working relationship between John Holland and Joseph Buck.

Looking Glass Curtain, Royal Coburg Theatre, 1820s.

Royal Coberg Theatre in 1826. Image from British History Online.

 

Joseph Buck, 164 Waterloo Road, Lambeth, 1870 London Post Office Directory.

 

 

Street numbers on Waterloo Rd./St. were reconfigured rather than Joseph Buck moving the warehouse.

Joseph Buck, 164 Waterloo Rd., 1893 London Post Office Directory.

1893 was the latest Buck address on Waterloo Rd. that I have found to date.

 

 

Joseph Buck married Margaret Richardson (1803-1863) , 22 August, 1822, at St. Luke’s, Finsbury.

Joseph Buck, “Tool Maker, employs 6 men,” 91 Waterloo Road, Lambeth, 1851 U.K. census.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Joseph Buck was awarded “Freedom of the City,” admission papers on 20 January, 1836.

Joseph Buck, circa 1860.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Joseph Buck, 124 Newgate St., London; 1 Waterloo St., in Robson’s 1835 London Trade Directory.

Ambition and drive were qualities that Joseph Buck possessed in spades.  Joseph provided the initiative that established the Buck tool dynasty, which still trades  today.

 

Joseph & George Buck at 245 Tottenham Court Road, in Robson’s 1835 London Trade Directory.

George Buck, alone, also at 245 Tottenham Court Road, in Robson’s 1835 London Trade Directory.

 

 

 

 

Before George Buck was listed as proprietor of the business at 245 Tottenham Court Road circa 1838, that address was under the auspices of his older brother, Joseph Buck.  A Sun Fire Insurance Policy record from 5 November, 1834 (policy #1187028) revealed business owner “Joseph Buck of No. 245 Tottenham Court Road, Saw, Plane, File and Tool Maker.”  A later Sun Insurance document from the same policy, referred to the business as “J. Buck, now George Buck of 245 Tottenham Court Road,” on 20 September, 1854.  Even earlier, the 1832 Robson’s London Street directory listed both “Joseph and George Buck” at 245 Tottenham Court Road.  Information for the 1832 Robson’s directory would have been taken in the Fall of 1831.

Joseph & George Buck in Robson’s 1832 London Trade Directory.

28 Brick Lane, Spitalfields may have been the actual saw making facility long searched for.  This is the earliest document for Buck at 245 Tottenham Court Road that I have found to date.

 

Last known listing for Matthew Buck, in Robson’s 1833 London Trade Directory.

The Buck Clan, Robson’s 1833 London Trade Directory.

 

 

 

 

George Buck, 1841 U.K. census, 245 Tottenham Court Road, “Saw Maker.”

 

George and Mary were living together at 245 Tottenham Court Road, with their third child, more than 11 years before their marriage to each other.

 

Geo. Buck, 1851 UK census. “Tool Warehouse employing 8 men.” 245 Tottenham Court Road.

At the time of the 1851 census, George and Mary Buck and their children were living in the housing quarters above the tool warehouse which was on the ground floor.

 

George Buck marriage to Mary Fullagar, 18 August, 1852. William Fullagar also lived at 245 Tot. Ct. Rd.

Typical of the mid-19th century, George Buck had a large family: George married Mary Fullagar and they had at least nine children.  Or more accurately, George and Mary had a lot of children, then they got married.

George Buck and Mary Fullagar: “Of full age.”

Dissolution of a second short-lived partnership: between George Buck and John Roe Hickman Jr. (1829-1904) From the London Gazette, 29 February, 1856.

 

Not to be confusing, George Henry Buck (1825-1891), son of Joseph, married his first cousin, Isabella Hickman.  George Henry took over the business of Richard Nelson at 122 Edgware Road circa 1850.  In around 1893, George Ryan, a manager for George Henry since 1870, bought the business and it became Ryan & Buck.  By 1910 the name was switched to Buck & Ryan.  The Joseph Buck company, however, continued to trade independently until liquidation in 1922.

John Roe Hickman Sr. was a printer by trade.

 

George Henry Buck married Isabella Hickman at St. Mary’s, Whitechapel on 7 June, 1851.

 

George Henry and Isabella had at least six children.  Both fathers were “Toolmakers.”

 

 

 

On  26 February, 1865, George Buck passed away at age 59.  Many of the best years for George Buck’s business were still ahead of them, and their successors actively maintained the tool business into the 1980s.

Buck left a good legacy, but he also had many heirs.

It was George Buck’s tool warehouse, which was most closely associated with fine infill planes and piano tools from 1838 to World War One.  Joseph Buck, however, did sell Towell planes in the 1830s and ’40s, and Buck & Ryan sold some Norris planes in the 1920s and ’30s.

Proprietary stamps for “BUCK” metal planes rarely included a first initial after 1850 or so.  This differed from items marked specifically “G. BUCK,” such as bow drill stocks, saws, piano tools, chisels, braces, and wooden planes.  Since a fair amount of capitol was tied up with metal infill planes, it would be a reasonable assumption that all three Buck businesses participated in selling these products by pooling their money.

George Buck, death certificate. Died 26 February, 1865, from bronchitis.  Ann Hickman present at death.

 

George Buck interment, All Souls Cemetery, Kendall Green.

 

 

 

 

 

Joseph Buck, in the Probate Index, died 18 April, 1884.

Probate Index (continued).

 

 

 

 

£23,000 in 1884 equals about $3,500,000 in today’s dollars.  On average, businesses which sold tools as a concerted and organised effort, along with making tools, or dealers who traded in tools exclusive from making them, did better financially than those who primarily focused on making tools.

John Roe Hickman Jr., (1828-1904).

John Roe Hickman in the Probate Calendar.

 

 

 

£65,847 in 1904 would be almost $10,000,000 in today’s dollars.  And that’s with the low value of today’s GBP compared with the USD.

For comparison, Sheffield edgetool maker William Butcher died with a fortune of £100,000 in 1870. Scottish-born steel magnate Andrew Carnegie amassed a fortune of $380,000,000 or $309 Billion in today’s currency.

 

Joseph Buck’s 1912 Pianoforte and Organ Builders’ catalogue offered 5 sizes of mitre planes, 3 types of thumb planes, and 2 sizes of panel planes.  All of the mitre planes and at least two out of three of the thumb planes would have been made by Norris, because that was where Buck was sourcing most of his infill planes just before The Great War. What planes were included, as well as the planes that were omitted, provide insight into which actual planes were in demand for purchase within the piano industry.  Following logically, this gave an indication around what planes were used more and what was used less.  No smooth planes were included in this list for pianomakers, which could indicate that bevel up planes were used in common practice for a wider range of tasks, including at least some smoothing.

Joseph Buck piano tools, in the 1912 Catalogue.

Buck and piano tools: Music Trades Directory 1912.  I have a signed George Buck tuning hammer with a previous mark filed off, quite probably R. Reynolds, who provided Buck with most of his specialized piano tools.

 

George Buck’s Tool Warehouse, 242 Tottenham Court Road, circa 1890.  Left window: “Pianoforte Makers; Carpenters; Coach Makers & Engineer’s Tools.”

245 Tottenham Court Road, from John Tallis’ Street View Map of London circa 1838-1840.  Image from the Museum of London.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Change of addresses may have been renumbering rather than actual moves.  Buck was trading at no. 245 before 1840 when information was taken for the map.

The Bucks as Saw Makers

All census information, except the address were obtained by the resident’s response to the census takers’ questions.  Are they the last word in defining the vocation of these planemakers?  Not necessarily, but given the relative dearth of information for these individuals, it’s one of the best references we have under the circumstances.  The working classes and skilled craftspeople of the 19th century and earlier were not generally people of letters, so there is less information to work with than the more academically educated classes.  They were smart in other ways.

Illiterate “X” signature on early mitre plane.

 

Many early wills were signed with an “X” not unlike this example.

 

 

 

 

Here is an example of this census reporting issue.  George Buck was known as a tool dealer rather than a maker, but in 1861, he described his business as a “Saw Manufacturer.”  After all, George’s father Matthew made saws, and George must have possessed the know-how to make saws, at the least.

George Buck and family, “Saw Manufacturers,” U.K. census, 1861.

Another large tool dealer, Moseley, also described their business as a manufacturer of tools, and for a number of years, they had a horse mill at the rear of their premises.  I could find no evidence to date of an in-house shop at 245 Tottenham Court Road making tools from scratch.  Perhaps George Buck owned an off-premises saw making shop we do not know about.

George Buck, 1840 London Post Office Directory.

George Buck, 1865 London P.O. Directory.

George Buck, 1921 London P.O. Directory.

Consistently during George Buck’s life, and after his death, the Buck business was listed as a  saw maker.  Multiple sources for this lends credibility that the G. Buck firm actually did make saws, and possibly some other tools such as files.  On the other hand, they could have been sold on the idea of being recognized as a maker of tools. At various times, all of the Buck firms listed their business under “saw, file, and plane makers.”  This included Joseph Buck, Buck & Hickman, and George Henry Buck.  Patriarch, saw and filemaker Matthew Buck (1776-1844) must have exerted a lifetime influence on his children.

George Buck Invoice header from 1896.

Making Saws. From “The Working Man,” 3 February, 1866.

 

 

 

 

 

Illustrations showed phases of saw making: cutting, grinding, and punching teeth with a fly press.  Not included was a furnace.

 

Joseph Buck ad in the Lambeth and Southwark Advertiser 6 October, 1859.

George Buck’s siblings also identified themselves as “Saw and Toolmakers.”

Buck & Hickman, London Post Office Directory, 1843.

Joseph Buck, London Post Office Directory, 1843.

 

George Buck (1805-1865)George Buck in sartorial splendor.  (1805-1865).

Tottenham Court Road street scene in the 1880s.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Iron planemaker Richard Bywater, P.O. Directory 1805; 72 Tottenham Court Road (<1794-1807); 218 Tot. Ct. Rd. (1808-1814>).  Much earlier, but worth inclusion.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Section of a detailed London map, by the Ordnance Survey in 1893-96.  George Buck’s tool warerooms at 245, 247, 242 Tottenham Ct. Rd (1831-1930; 21 Goodge St. 1938-80>), and his neighbors in allied trades during the 1860s-90s: J. & J. Goddard, piano supplies, 68 Tottenham Court Road (1842-1968); Richard Reynolds, piano ironmonger/toolsmith, 4 Upper Rathbone Place (<1880-1895; in Hammersmith to 1940); George Kerr, planemaker,  36 Store St. Bedford Square (c. 1864-65)

G.Buck ad in “The Forcept; Journal of Dental Surgery,” circa 1844.

 

 

From the establishment of his business in 1831, George Buck supplied a wide range of trades and professions.  These dental instruments make me appreciate living in the 21st century.

 

E. Weller’s 1868 London Map, section with Lambeth.

Map section shows the following: Joseph Buck, brother of George Buck, b 1802. planemaker and dealer, 164 Waterloo Rd. (1824-1893); Charles Badger, iron planemaker, 1 Stangate St. (1854-68) 93 York Rd. (1868-70); John Holland, planemaker, 68 Oakley St. (1861-71), 93 York Rd. 1870-90); Thomas Norris tool and planemaker 57 York St. (<1871-1905).

 

 

 

Buck/Towell

Towell mitre plane, marked and sold by Buck (1831-1861).

Buck (Towell) mitre plane, stamped 245 Tottenham Court Road., dating from the early 1830s and through the 1850s.  By 1851, George Buck’s business had grown to the point where 8 men were employed there, as reported in the UK census.  245 Tottenham Ct. Rd.was George Buck’s address from 1838 to 1861. The “BUCK 245 TOTTENHAM Ct. Rd.” stamp used the same lettering font/format as the “Rt. TOWELL LONDON” stamps.  It makes for a strong indication that Robert Towell himself applied these stamps in his workshop.  For more information on Robert Towell, see the page on Early English Mitre Planes. This plane is also very similar, if not identical to the one used to plane spotted metal for organ pipes at G. Fincham Organ Builders. 

Towell mitre plane, marked on rear infill, and Buck marked on the bridge.

Dual marked plane: Buck on bridge and Towell on rear infill.  Someone lost their patience with this tool, and filed the mouth open.  Photo by Robert Leach. From website http://www.oldhandtools.co.uk/blog/english-mitre-planes

 

 

Mitre plane bridge made by Robert Towell, but marked Joseph Buck 124 Newgate St., London (also 91 Waterloo Rd.., Lambeth).  Photo from Hans Brunner 2016.

© 2020 – Martin Shepherd Piano Service  Using the text, research, or images on this website without permission on an ebay auction or any other site is a violation of federal law in most countries.

Buck/Holland

The following two Buck mitre planes share similar fundamental aspects as well as many details.  Considering the similarities of these two Buck mitre planes, its apparent they were made by the same maker, and  I believe that was John Holland (1830-1912).

Holland mitre plane (attributed), marked by Buck.

 

Sole of Buck mitre plane with small mouth.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This is the earlier version of this type of Buck mitre plane; 245 Tottenham Court Road, probably circa 1862-66, when the address was actually 245-247 Tottenham Court Road. The stamp is otherwise the same as the other post 1880 Buck mitre, shown down the page, with similar features, including the convex bridge.  The bridge is less convex than the later mitre, but it is still noticeable.

 

DSC01882

Holland mitre plane, marked and sold by Buck, post 1880.

 

Second Buck/Holland mitre plane, convex bridge, with Cupid’s bow.  Buck, 242 Tottenham Court Road, post 1880.  Its unusual to see many box mitre planes made after 1860, and more so to see a plane with a cupid’s bow bridge after the 1870s.

 

 

 

Dovetailed George Buck mitre plane, 242 Tottenham Court Road, London. Most likely made by John  Holland; bed, iron, and wedge all have  matched fitting numbers. Post 1880, as Buck occupied 242 Tottenham Court Road from 1880 to 1930.   There is a very small set of J H initials up near the nib. Buck must have been strict about not revealing the makers of his planes.

Here are some similarities listed:

  1. Layout of dovetails.
  2. Shape of heels.
  3. Shape of rear flanges.
  4. Very small mouths..
  5. Front and rear sole piece dovetailed together at mouth.
  6. Shape and moulding of front infills.
  7. Profile of wedges.
  8. Style of cupid’s bow.
  9. Convex curvature of bridge.
  10. Same species of rosewood.

These Buck mitres are different in the following ways:

  1. Different shape for front flanges (see pictures).
  2. 245 Tottenham Court Rd. has a slightly curved bridge, while curvature on 242 Tottenham Court Rd. is pronounced.
  3. Infills on 245 are screwed in at the toe and heel, and 242 was pinned through the sidewalls.

Holland mitre plane (Buck) bridge, circa 1861-1866.

BUCK marked bridge, with initials J H scratched in or acid etched. This is exactly the same photograph that was previously posted, when I had initially thought the plane was made by Norris. Some of the letters are now circled, most of which run along near the left cheek of the plane.  Some markings have JH letters running together, sharing the left vertical line of the H, in a monogram. It must be where Thomas Norris got the idea for his TN monogram.  Circa 1862 to 1866, when Mrs. G. Buck was at 245 and 247 Tottenham Court Road.

When John Holland would have made the  Buck 245 Tottenham Court Road plane in the 1860s, he would have been just starting in his career.  It makes sense that Holland would try to take credit for the plane, because most people starting out in a career have something to prove.  That may be why the later Buck planes, that were unmistakably from the same maker, did not have such prominent markings.  Subsequent mitre planes coming from John Holland, and rebadged as BUCK, more often than not, had identification relegated to J H initials on the cutting irons.  If any at all.

In addition to the convex shape of the bridge, the cupid’s bows were not deeply cut as one would expect to generally see from Robert Towell.  Cupid’s bows were identical for  all 245, 247 and 242 Tottenham Court Road marked bridges shown on this page for comparison.  Letters for “BUCK” are more spaced apart than Towell’s stamp, and the address is done with fine incuse letters with a slant, in Gothic.  Holland/Buck used this stamp from the 1860s to ~1890, when Norris/Buck switched to “BUCK Tot. Court Rd.” in small upright Gothic letters.  A variation of this post 1885–90 stamp read “BUCK Tottm. Ct. Rd.”  These later stamps seem to be applied by the Buck the dealer, rather than the maker, as they are sometimes found not perfectly straight.  The slanted Gothic lettering stamp was used during the tenure with Holland, from the late 245 Tottenham Court Road address, throughout the 247 Tot. Ct. Rd. period from 1867 to 1879, and into the 1880s at 242 Tot.Ct. Rd.

Convex bridge from Buck/Holland mitre plane, showing address of 247 Tottenham Court Road, circa 1867 to 1879.  Note the same stamp format as well as an identical cupid’s bow to the two mitres shown here. Photo from internet source.

Bridge of a Norris no. 10 mitre plane, which was marked 11.   Photo from Ebay UK, May 2019.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Norris no. 11 bridge has similarities with the Buck mitres in question. Because of these similarities, Thomas Norris cannot be ruled out. In any case, there was a significant gap in time between production of the last Buck/Holland type mitres in the 1880s, and the introduction of the Norris no. 11 small box mitre circa 1910-1914.  Only a few of these were made.

Considering that Buck bought in planes from Towell, Spiers, Slater, Holland, Miller, and Norris, which of these makers can be eliminated as the possible maker?  Since the two Buck planes with a convex cupid’s bow bridge were dovetailed, only Spiers, Holland, and Norris dovetailed their mitre planes.  Towell dovetailed his planes as well, but his productive years (1810-1863 at the very latest) were too early for consideration here.  These planes were made ~ 1860s to 1890.  Miller did not make any mitre planes, and his planes were all cast in gunmetal.  Slater made a modest number of cast iron mitre planes, appearing mostly unmarked, or rebadged, such as for Tyzack or Moseley.  Buck sell rebadged Spiers planes, and three examples can be seen below.  They do not appear to be different from Spiers signed planes in any way.  This is to be expected, as it would be unlikely for a plane maker to sell their planes at a lower price, wholesale to the trade, with any special new designs or modifications unless required by the dealer.

Buck/Spiers

Buck/Spiers mitre plane, 245 Tottenham Court Road, circa 1855-1865.

Early Spiers mitre plane marked “Buck 245 Tottenham Court Road.”  Stewart Spiers sold many early planes to Buck, Moseley, Mathiesen, and Archer, as well as other dealers.  Planes were either rebadged  by the tool dealers, or by Spiers himself.  Some early Spiers examples were never stamped with a mark at all.   After 1880, Stewart Spiers apparently did not need to sell his products wholesale to the trade.

 

Spiers mitre plane, eight inches long, as in 1850s Spiers price list.  Photo from Spiers.planes.com

 

 

A similar 8″ Spiers mitre plane to the example above: with early style front infill, early lever cap screw, squared-off flanges, double bend in sidewalls at heel, rear flange (not exclusively a later feature for 8″ examples), side screws for attaching lever cap, and a relatively short neck on lever cap.

 

 

 

 

 

Buck (Spiers) mitre plane, c. 1870s. Standard Spiers design. Warman’s Price Guide, Clarence Blanchard, 2011.

Buck/Spiers mitre,1870s. Photo by Bill Carter.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Buck (Spiers) panel plane lever cap, 247 Tottenham Court Road, circa 1867-1879.

 

 

This was among the last Spiers planes to be bought in and rebadged by a dealer.  A few later examples can be found, having  lever cap screws without cusps, but they are scarce.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Holland would be the remaining possible maker of these dovetailed mitre planes, other than Norris, and there’s a shortfall of Holland’s  examples available for comparison.  What makes these two planes unusual, even unique, is that they seem to be limited to the Buck dealer stamp, and do not appear elsewhere with the original planemaker’s stamp.  Of course a maker-stamped mitre might show in the future, and if it does, it could give a more definitive answer as to who made all the Buck mitres with cupid’s bow and curved bridges, from the 1860s and into the 1880s.  While these Buck mitres are rare, a fair number of this vintage and type  have shown up over the years.

In recent years, antique tool dealers and auctioneers have proffered their own assessment as to the identity of the maker of these mitre planes.  Two tool dealers and one auctioneer advanced Norris as the likely maker, and one auctioneer proposed Holland.  A rebadged Norris plane has a greater potential to achieve higher prices, so this evaluation may not be entirely objective.

Working years for Holland ranged from 1861 to 1905, which encompassed the time in the 1860s when the earlier plane was made.  While Norris advertised that he was established in 1860, it was realistically more as a maker of wood planes and other joiners’ tools early on.  Thomas Norris (1836-1906), described his profession in the 1861 UK census as a non-specific “Joiners’ tool maker,” then in the 1871 UK census as a “Tool maker;”  and finally in the 1881 UK census as a “Plane tool maker.” 

Some Holland Family History:

John Holland was born in Riby, Brocklesby, Lincoln, which is near the South shore of the Humber estuary on the East coast.  His parents were John and Mary Holland, and he was baptized on 4 July, 1830, in Riby.

John Holland married Sophia Swann at the Cathedral of St. Peter & Paul, in Sheffield, on 26 September, 1852.

Sophia Swann (1830-1901<) was born in the hamlet of Dalham, Suffolk County.  John and Sophia had four children: James Henry, born 1853 in Sheffield; Mary Agnes, born 1856 in Sheffield; Harold Charles, born 1858 in Lambeth; Samuel Swann (1868-1951).  By 1858, John Holland and his family relocated to Lambeth, and John established a home and workshop at 68 Oakley Street as recorded in the 1861 U.K. census.

Oakley St. Renumbering plan, 2 March 1877.

 

John Holland’s 68 Oakley St. address (<1861-1869) is marked on this map excerpt.

–Old numbers in black, new (1877) numbers in red.  Gibson St. crossed out and replaced with Oakley St. (see Horwood’s Plan c. 1819, above).

 

 

John Holland, “Tool Maker,” in Kelly’s l861 London Post Office Directory.

John Holland, listed in the London P.O. Directory for 1870, under “Metal Merchants.”

Holland wasted no time establishing his tool making business.

 

Early on, John Holland concentrated on metal tools, and was even listed as a dealer in gunmetal stock in 1870.

John Holland moved to 93 York Road. 1872 London Post Office Directory.

 

93 York Road was the former workshop and living quarters of Charles and Isabella Badger.  Charles Badger died 28 September, 1869.

 

York Road scene, circa 1890s.

 

York Road was a busy thoroughfare, which ran between Waterloo Road and Westminster Bridge Road, with the large South Western Railway Station positioned in between these two intersections.  93 York Road was a good, high visibility workshop location for Charles Badger (1868-1869), and John Holland (1870-1890).  Thomas Norris Jr. and Sr. rented 23 York Road from <1898-1915.

 

John Holland, in the 1880 London Post Office Directory.

John Holland, “Mechanical Tool Maker, Employs Two Men” in the 1881 U. K. census.

“Gunmetal, iron, plane, saw, file. & mechanical tool maker & dealer:”  Holland was making a wide range of products. Not just planes.

Many Holland planes were bought in by tool dealers such as George Buck, many were stamped “J. Holland,” and many were sold unmarked.  Holland was a prolific maker, and having a crew of two men–and an apprentice or two–made this possible.

 

John Holland was involved in two newsworthy incidents during his career:

South London Press, 28 April, 1883, part 2..

South London Press, 28 April, 1883.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

“Yesterday shortly before ten a loud explosion was heard in the neighbourhood of Westminster Bridge Road causing considerable alarm.  The police ascertained that a serious explosion had occurred at the tool and cutlery establishment of Mr. Holland at 93, York Raod.  It appeared that at the time the son of the proprieter Samuel Holland aged 17, upon entering the parlour at the rear of the shop had smelt strong of gas.  Unfortunately he sought the cause with a naked light, shattering the windows in the shop and damaging the display trade, which fortunately will not prevent the business from being carried on as usual.”–Clerkenwell News, 24 April, 1885.

John Holland, 26 Richmond St. St. George’s road S E, in the 1890 London Post office Directory.

By the 1891 U.K. census, John Holland was living at 25 St. Mary’s Square in Lambeth, while the P.O. directories listed Holland at 26 Richmond, St. George Road through 1893. After John Holland left 93 York Rd., he did not retire.

John Holland, “Tool Manufacturer,” in the 1895 London Post Office Directory.

John Holland moved to 30 Garden Row sometime before the fall of 1894, and stayed there until at least 1905.  He continued to make tools during this time.

 

Holland and his family remained involved in gunmetal and iron planemaking as well as making other woodworking tools into the twentieth century. Sons Harold C. and Samuel became involved in the tool business to various degrees in the 1890s and into the early 20th centuries at several addresses.  During the 1901 census, John Holland, 70, “Carpenter and Joiner,” was living at 30 Garden Row, in Southwark along with his younger sister Mercy, 66.  John was listed in the London P.O. Directory for 1902 as a “Tool Manufacturer.”

John Holland, “Tool Manufacturer,” 30 Garden Row, London P.O. Directory, 1902.

John and sister Mercy Holland, 30 Garden Row, in the 1901 U.K. census.

 

 

 

John Holland, in the 1905 London Post Office Directory.

By 1905, Holland had been working for over 55 years.

 

 

John Holland, 80, retired “carpenter,” Tooting Bec Asylum, Wandsworth, 1911 U.K. census.

John Holland’s death certificate.

John Holland passed away in Wandsworth on 12 October, 1912.  81 (actually 82) was truly an advanced age for the time.  John Holland was one of the most long lived planemakers compared to all his peers.

 

John Holland’s decision to move to Wandsworth may have been influenced by planemaker Thomas Norris (1835-1906).  Norris had already moved to 6 Quarry Road in Wandsworth by 1900, as recorded in the P.O. Directory.  John Holland and Thomas Norris had been longtime neighbors in Lambeth, they must have consulted each other as influences between them are apparent in their planes.  This does not necessarily imply that there was a formal collaboration between them; sole proprietors by definition have always been recognized for having a strong independent streak. It was also likely that John and Thomas were friends.  Thomas Norris was born in Lambeth, and he remained there to live and work until his move to Wandsworth.

© 2020 – Martin Shepherd Piano Service   Using the text, research, or images on this website without permission on an ebay auction or any other site is a violation of federal law in most countries.

Some Norris Family History:

Thomas Norris (the elder) was baptized 30 December, 1804, at St. Mary’s Church in Lambeth.

Thomas’ parents were George Norris (1773-1845), and Rebecca Cooper, (1775-1843).  George and Rebecca were married in 1802.

 

Thomas Norris married Jane Taylor at St. Savior Church in Southwark, 3 July, 1827.

 

Thomas (1804-1886) and Jane (1803-1871) had the following children: Jane (1831-1878), Thomas James (1835-1906), Edmund (1837-1928), Sarah, (1840-1910), Rebecca, born 1842, Harriet Mary, (1847-1919), and Warnell, born 1847.

 

 

Thomas Norris Sr.’s baptism, 22 July, 1835, at St. Mary’s in Lambeth.

 

Thomas James Sr. was an engraver on George St. in Lambeth.

 

Thomas Sr, 16, was an “errand boy” in 1851.

Thomas Norris Sr. on George St., Lambeth, in the 1841 U.K. census.

Thomas and Jane Norris, at 18 Northings Head Yard, Lambeth, in the 1851 U.K. census.

 

 

 

 

Thomas James Norris married Eliza Knott, on 15 May. 1859, at St. Mary’s Church, Lambeth.

Thomas married Eliza Knott (1839-1918), and surviving children (from as many as 7) included: Thomas James (1860-1936); Ada Jane, (1862-1944); Clances (1868-1871>), Elizabeth (1870-1949); Edith A.(1874-1959).  In 1859, Thomas was a “tool maker.”

Thomas Norris Sr., and Jane, with Jane Knott, born 1857, 25 King’s Head Yard, Lambeth.  1861 U.K. census.

 

 

In 1861, Thomas Sr. and Jane were taking care of Jane Knott, granddaughter, born 1857.

 

Thomas Norris I’s 1873 admission to Lambeth Workhouse.

 

Thomas Norris (1804-1886) was a music engraver, which was a skill that involved a great deal of precision.  By the 1870s and 1880s, Norris the elder was admitted several times to the workhouse.

 

Thomas Norris, “Music Engraver,” in the Lambeth Workhouse, U.K. census, 1881.

Thomas Norris in the Death index, first quarter, 1886.

 

Thomas J. Norris was born 27 June, 1860, and was baptized 22 July, 1866 at St. John the Evangelist, Lambeth.

.

 

Thomas Norris Jr. (1860-1936) was the oldest son: first the apprentice, then partner and successor to his father in the business of making tools.  Both father and son were baptized on 22 July.

 

 

Buck/Norris

Thomas J. Norris Sr.’s early success as a plane and toolmaker was due, in major part, to his business relationship with George Buck.  Many early Norris planes were bought in by Buck and rebadged “BUCK.” This connection between Buck and Norris, was far from exclusive, however.  A Buck infill plane with what appears to be Norris-like features may actually not be made by Norris.  John Holland had an established business relationship with Buck as well, and Holland had a major influence on Norris’ planemaking.  The same could be said of Stewart Spiers.  Mitre planes shown here serve as an example of Holland’s stylistic influence on Norris.  Norris did establish a tool making business circa 1860, so it turns out that later Norris advertising was not an exaggeration.

Norris, 1861 U.K. census, 35 Elliotts Row, Lambeth.

Norris, 1871 U.K. census, 57 York St., Lambeth.

 

Early census and city directory information for Norris indicate that he produced joiner’s tools of a general nature, rather than specializing in planes.

 

 

 

Norris’ entry 1870 P.O. Directory.

Norris 1881 U.K. census, “Plane Tool Maker.”  Thomas Jr. also working with his father; he probably started circa 1875.

 

 

 

Thomas Norris 1890 London P.O. Directory, the earliest entry I have found to date specific to “Iron Plane Maker.

Kelly’s London P.O. Directory for 1899. Earliest entry found to date with Thomas Jr. listed as partner

 

 

 

 

After John Holland left 93 York Road in 1890, but before Thomas Norris rented 23 York Road <1898, the East side of York Road was renumbered.  93 York Road became no. 5 York Road.  In the “Survey of London: Volume 23, Lambeth: Southbank and Vauxhall,” published 1951, the East side of York Street was described thusly:

“Nos. 3-13 (formerly nos. 91-96)

These houses were erected on the York Road frontage of Field’s property circa 1829. They form a simple terrace in stock brick having a continuous dentil cornice to the parapet above the second story. The individual houses are, however, emphasized by the rectangular recesses in the parapet over each and by the narrow vertical inset panels separating them. Nos. 3–9 have balconies, those to the remaining houses having been removed when shop fronts were inserted.

In the 19th century these houses were largely used by dramatic agents and as lodging houses for members of the theatrical profession who were in low water; they earned the sobriquet of Poverty Corner.

Nos. 15-23 (formerly Nos. 97-101)

These houses were similar in character to Nos. 3–13 though they were built a year or two later. They were demolished in 1950 for road improvements.

Nos. 57-69 (formerly Nos. 1-5 Commercial Place and Nos. 132 and 133 York Road)

These houses, dating from 1843–5, were among the last to be erected in the road.”

Lambeth Ordnance Survey Map, circa 1872, showing locations of Planemakers Thomas Norris Sr., and John Holland.

 

 

 

 

 

Norris’ 1901 census entry at 6 Quarry Rd.,Wandsworth: “Tool (Iron Plane) Manufacturing

Norris’ 1905 P.O. directory entry at 57 York St. with encroaching rail station.

 

 

 

 

 

57 York St. in the 1901 U.K. census. Street fully populated.

 

 

Norris had moved to Wandsworth in late 1899, but continued to rent 57 York St. as well as 23 York Road, which was used in their 1908 catalogue.  Note that York St. was fully populated in 1901.  The buyouts and evictions were later, circa 1903-1904.  Norris was still listed at 57 York St. in the London 1905 P.O. directory as seen above.

 

 

An improvement in means was the reason behind the Norris family leaving 57 York Street, rather than pressure from the railroad.  Norris’ sales of fine metal planes were finally paying dividends.  Norris employee Charles Henry Payne explained the move.  Regarding 57 York Street, Payne revealed that “The Norris family lived in rooms above the works, and another family lived above that.  As the family became better off they moved home to Quarry Road Wandsworth, but retained the works in York Street.”

Railroad map, circa 1900-1905, showing proposed area of eminent domain around York St. Map from George Anderson. George found this while researching at the Lambeth Archive, at the Minet Library.

Construction of the Waterloo station began in the 1840s, but it continued on and off throughout the remainder of the 19th century.  By the early 1890s, it became clear that the piecemeal approach led to poor planning and that a more unified concept would require a complete rebuild.  The only remaining structure from the the original would be the large supporting arches over the marshy soil.

 

Sketch of York Road in the 1940s with Norris’ rental at 23 delineated. Image from George Anderson, who found it doing research at the Lambeth Archive, Minet Library, in Lambeth.

 

 

 

 

Thomas rented 23 York Road from as early as 1898 to 1915, when costs from the Great War economy were felt throughout Europe.  Thomas Norris Jr. survived the War with some government contracts which granted him access to the metals that he needed.  Norris’ 1913 patent for a plane adjustment mechanism, both depth and lateral, solidified his position as the leading high end metal planemaker in the U.K.

 

 

Thomas J. Norris Sr. death certificate, 6 Quarry Rd., Wandsworth, Surrey, 15 April, 1906

Thomas Norris Sr. in the Probate Calendar.

Postcard of Sycamore Grove, New Malden, looking West, circa 1906, when Thomas Norris Jr. moved in. From the collection of George Anderson.

 

Senility was an issue during Thomas James Norris Sr.’s final months.

 

 

£230 would be about $32,250 today.  Estate was dated 27 September, 1906.

 

Thomas Jr. was on the move and went out and bought a home at 3 Sycamore Grove, New Malden on 23 September 1906. Soon after, work began on building a fairly large new workshop/factory on the land next his Victorian house.  Money was available for construction, but not for a headstone at Thomas Sr.’s grave.

3 Sycamore Grove is on the right, with just a corner of the house exposed.   Thank you George Anderson for these wonderful images!   The Norris property had a 120 foot frontage, with a 200 foot depth,  and the shop was built circa 1907-1909.

Map with footprint of workshop/factory and house at 3 Sycamore Grove, New Malden, circa 1935. From collection of George Anderson.

Map with footprint of 3 Sycamore Grove, New Malden, with house and proposed workshop, circa 1907.  From collection of George Anderson.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thomas J. Norris married Helen Sellars Walker, 22 March, 1909, at St. Anne’s in Wandsworth.

 

Thomas Jr., 49, married Helen Sellars Walker, 44.  It was a late marriage for both of them.  Helen was living at 6 Quarry Rd., Wandsworth, Thomas Sr.’s former house.

 

 

1911 U.K. census. Thomas Norris, Iron Planemaker.

1911 U.K. census, part two. “Marizion,” and Thomas Norris signature.

 

 

 

Ordnance Survey Map of New Malden, Surrey County, 1897. Detail of Sycamore Grove.

The Royal Oak Pub, at 90 Coombe Road, was Norris’ neighbor on the East side of 3 Sycamore Grove.  This map was drawn up about 10 years before Thomas Norris took possession of the property.

Sycamore Grove photo, looking East, towards Coombe Road.  Photo from the collection of George Anderson.

 

 

This photo was taken circa 1900, and was found in the Lambeth Archive, at the Minet Library.  A horse drawn wagon was used for delivering goods to the Royal Oak Pub, and you can see the silhouette of a person on the sidewalk.  In the left foreground was the sidewalk frontage of  “Marizion,” 3 Sycamore Grove, Norris’ home and workshop.

 

 

 

Buck/Holland (continued)

In comparison to Thomas Norris Sr.’s early generalized production, John Holland’s early specialization in metal planemaking was evident from extant early examples of his planes, and in historical documentation.  During the 1850s, John Holland lived in the Sheffield area, which was a hotbed of innovation in metallurgy.  Holland’s description of his business underscored his initial involvement in iron and gunmetal planemaking.

Searching for an apprentice 1864, John Holland posted the following ad in the “Clerkenwell News:”  March 23, 1864:

“Apprentice wanted to the Gun Metal, Iron Plane and Mechanical Tool Manufacturing, a small premium required,  Apply to Mr. J. Holland at 68 Oakley Street, Lambeth.”

In 1869, John Holland was listed in “Kelly’s, Post Office and Harrod & Co., Trade Directory” as a “Gun[metal] and Iron Plane Maker,”

1870 London P.O. Directory: “John Holland, Gunmetal & Iron Planemaker.  68 Oakley Street, Lambeth. S.E.”

Since John Holland took over established metal planemaker, Charles Badger’s workshop and tools at 93 York Rd. Lambeth in 1870, he would have been thoroughly prepared to produce infill planes during this early time period.  By the time of the 1881 UK census, John Holland employed two men besides himself for his tool making enterprise.

A definitive Norris no. 10 mitre plane is shown rebadged as a Buck further down this page.  There are no differences between the Buck and a Norris no. 10 other than  the stamp on the bridge.

Below you can see the curved bridges of both Norris and Holland.  The influence of Holland on Norris is obvious.  And that applies to the two previous Buck mitre planes as well.

Holland mitre plane, formerly from the Max Ott collection.

Holland bridge on smooth plane.  Photo from Ar.clarence, pinterest

Norris gunmetal bridge from a no.10 mitre plane.  Mitre and smoothing planes with this bridge can be found marked BUCK also.   Photo from Jim Bode.

 

Holland mitre plane-Mar. 2015 Brown auction.

Holland bridge. Norris’ bridge is quite similar.  Photo by Lee Richmond.

Later Buck stamp, found on rebadged Norris smoother and panel planes. Photo from Ebay U.K.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

100 years of Buck mitre planes.

 

 

 

 

Buck (all)

Left to right: Buck/Towell 245 Tottenham Court Road (1831-1861); Buck/Holland 245 Tottenham Court Road (1861-1866); Buck/Holland 247 Tottenham Court Road (1867-1879); Buck/Holland 242 Tottenham Court Road (1880-1890); Buck/Norris No. 10 “Tot.Ct.Rd.”(late1880s-<1914); Norris (Morris) A11 which was included in the 1938 Buck & Hickman Catalogue.